Today, the Senate confirmed Judge Michael Brennan to the Seventh Circuit and invoked cloture on Joel Carson (Tenth Circuit) and John Nalbandian (Sixth Circuit). The Senate Judiciary Committee favorably reported Mark Bennett (Ninth Circuit), Nancy E. Brasel (D. Minn.), Robert R. Summerhays (W.D. La.), and Eric C. Tostrud (D. Minn.) to the Senate.
In the past few days, the Senate Democrats have turned to complaining about Chairman Chuck Grassley's blue slip policy, instead of attacking these excellent nominees' qualifications and merits, which has been a largely failed strategy. Chairman Grassley defended his blue slip policy on the Senate floor yesterday, as we described in yesterday's blog post.
Chairman Grassley reiterated at today's Senate Judiciary meeting that rather than his blue slip policy being unprecedented, the obstruction and delays by the Senate Democrats are truly what is unprecedented. He described how blue slips entitle senators to consultation, not a one-person veto to the President's exercise of his authority. He has ensured that the purpose of the blue slip has been carried out for all nominees by requesting from the White House consultation logs for senators who have refused to return blue slips before he went ahead with hearings.
Senator Roy Blunt of Missouri also called out the Senate Democrats' obstruction on the Senate floor yesterday:
The fact that the Senate's time is taken in a way that it
never has been before to process the president's nominations is outrageous. It's just outrageous. There's some view that, well, we need more time to think
about the nominee. There's plenty of time to do that. It's called the committee
process. It's called a vetting process that also may very well take too long
now, but there is plenty of time for these circuit court nominees that we're
voting on this week to be vetted. There’s
plenty of time to ask them questions.
There’s plenty of time to look into their background.
The only reason, in my view, that we take the time we’re
taking to do six votes, basically six votes on six judges in a week. That's six
15-minute votes, if we were efficient enough to do that, that would be an hour
and a half we’d take to vote on these six judges, and the final vote on none of them would be different than taking five days. So why do you take five days? You take five days because that means we can’t
get to anything else. Not only does it mean that the President’s ability to populate the government, as people
elected him to do, is diminished, but
also it eliminates the time we have to do the other work that the Senate is
designed to do. The Senate is in, as the
Majority Leader likes to describe it, the personnel business, but it’s not
supposed to be the only business of the Senate.
I think we’ve [had] now over 90 of these cloture motions on
nominees that the President’s made.
90. Now, what does that
mean? In the previous six
administrations, in the first two years of each of them, there was a total of 24
cloture motions – . . . 24 times, six presidents, in the first two years, an average of four times. We’re going to
certainly be to 104 times well before the end of two years. . . .
No votes will be persuaded by running the clock. No votes will be changed by running the
clock. And the power, of course, to put
people on a federal bench for life is an important power given in the
Constitution to the President for the Supreme Court and such other courts as the
Congress may determine the country needs.
It’s not a thing to be taken lightly, but it’s also not a thing to be
abused. It’s not a process where the protection
that you might use four times in two years is suddenly used 90 times in 15
months. Something is wrong when that has
happened to the process.
The Senate will reconvene next week to consider cloture motions on three additional circuit court nominees and vote on the Carson and Nalbandian nominations. Thanks to Chairman Grassley, Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, and the Senate Republicans, the Democrats are only able to delay nominations and prevent the Senate from dealing with its other business but not ultimately prevent the confirmation of President Trump's excellent judicial nominees.
This week is a busy and important one for judicial confirmations. First, the Senate is taking confirmation votes on six excellent circuit court nominees: Michael B. Brennan (Seventh Circuit), Joel M. Carson (Tenth Circuit), Kurt D. Engelhardt (Fifth Circuit), John B. Nalbandian (Sixth Circuit), Michael Y. Scudder (Seventh Circuit), and Amy J. St. Eve (Seventh Circuit). The Senate invoked cloture on Judge Engelhardt's nomination this evening, 64 to 31.
Majority Leader McConnell is threatening to hold the Senate in session through the weekend to ensure that these nominees are confirmed. He said on the Senate floor earlier today:
This week, the Senate will consider another slate of extremely well-qualified nominees for seats on the federal bench. A thoughtful, independent, and expert judiciary is a cornerstone of our constitutional order. It’s been the case since the very beginning.
Accordingly, the six circuit court nominees we’ll now consider have excellent reputations in the legal field, and have demonstrated they understand the proper role of federal judges in our government. First up is Kurt Engelhardt of Louisiana, the president’s choice to serve on the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.
On Wednesday, the Senate Judiciary Committee will hold a hearing on Ryan Bounds (Ninth Circuit), J. Campbell Barker (Eastern District of Texas), Susan Brnovich (District of Arizona), Chad F. Kenney (Eastern District of Pennsylvania), Jeremy D. Kernodle (Eastern District of Texas), and Maureen K. Ohlhausen (Court of Federal Claims). On Thursday, the Committee will meet to vote on the nominations of Mark Bennett (Ninth Circuit), Andrew Oldham (Fifth Circuit), and eight district court nominees.
The Democrats and liberal activist groups have been busy smearing Ryan Bounds for months. They have been complaining about his nomination moving forward after Oregon's two extremely liberal, Democratic senators returned negative blue slips for him. Ed Whelan explained why this is sadly ironic:
Democratic senators Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley, along with Republican House member Greg Walden, formed a selection committee to rank candidates for federal judicial vacancies in Oregon. According to this February 2018 letter from Wyden and Merkley to White House counsel Don McGahn, the selection committee “consisted of eight highly experienced and diverse Oregon attorneys” who “carefully reviewed the applications of all the judicial candidates” and interviewed the finalists. Bounds emerged from this process as one of the selection committee’s “four highest ranked candidates” (“listed in alphabetical order”) for the very position to which Trump nominated him.
You’d think that the fact that the Wyden-Merkley selection committee ranked Bounds as one of the very top candidates would stand him in good stead with them. But Wyden and Merkley have not only declined to support his nomination and even returned negative blue slips on his nomination. . . .
Democratic Senator Mazie Hirono of Hawaii attempted, yet again, to distort the history on blue slips, but the Senate Judiciary Committee majority and RNLA member Ilya Shapiro corrected the misrepresentations in this Twitter thread.
Follow the RNLA on Twitter for updates on the latest judicial nomination and confirmation news.
During today's Senate Judiciary Committee hearing for Michael Brennan, nominated for the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, the Democrats objected to Chairman Grassley holding a hearing for Judge Brennan even though Senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin did not return her blue slip. There were even protesters in the gallery in blue shirts (part of an ongoing protest by the Center for American Progress and People for the American Way) and predictable gender-baiting by Democrats simply because Sen. Baldwin happens to be female.
But as Chairman Grassley pointed out in his opening statement, the consultation purpose of the blue slip has been fulfilled:
As I’ve explained, a negative
or unreturned blue slip won’t necessarily prevent a Circuit Court nominee from receiving a hearing,
unless the White House failed to consult with home-state senators before choosing the nominee.
After reviewing the record, it’s clear the White House adequately consulted with Senator Baldwin
regarding the nomination. In addition to Mr. Brennan, the White House also considered two
candidates Senator Baldwin suggested.
Senator Baldwin expressed to me that she’s frustrated by the state of Wisconsin’s judicial nominating
commission, which has been dysfunctional and unable to recommend candidates for judicial
vacancies. While I sympathize with this concern, the commission’s current shortcomings can’t be
allowed to impede the President’s constitutional duty to appoint federal judges.
I’ll also note that [Republican] Senator Johnson returned his blue slip for President Obama’s most recent nominee
for this seat last Congress, even though the commission had also failed to act in accordance with its
charter in that situation. I held a hearing for this nominee, and he was voted out of the Committee.
The Wisconsin judicial nominating commission is composed of six members, three from each party, and the support of five members is required for a judicial candidate to receive the commission's approval. Sen. Baldwin's reliance on the "dysfunctional" commission's approval in this case is inconsistent with her actions on this vacancy while President Obama was in office. Then, Sen. Baldwin submitted all eight potential nominees the commission had evaluated to President Obama for consideration. Only two of those nominees had received the supposedly “required” five votes. Apparently for Sen. Baldwin, the commission's approval is only important when there is a Republican in the White House. As Chairman Grassley pointed out, Judge Brennan was the only candidate reviewed by the commission since President Trump took office who received any bipartisan support.
As Chairman Grassley responded to Senator Sheldon Whitehouse complaining about his doing away with the blue slip policy, he is not doing away with blue slips (starting at 1:53:36). The role of blue slips is the prerogative of the Senate Judiciary Committee Chair, and he is keeping them as a way of ensuring consultation with home state senators by the White House. However, he pointed out that there will be exceptions, such as when the nominee is for a circuit court vacancy, the White House consulted with the home state senators, and a senator has stated politically motivated reasons for not returning the blue slip. Chairman Grassley is not going to allow Democratic senators, determined to cater to their radically liberal base and resist President Trump at every turn, to usurp President Trump's constitutional role of selecting federal judicial nominees.